Download Ordinary Meaning: A Theory of the Most Fundamental Principle by Brian G. Slocum PDF

By Brian G. Slocum

Consider this courtroom case: a defendant has traded a gun for medicinal drugs, and there's a legal sentencing provision that stipulates an greater punishment if the defendant “uses” a firearm “during and in terms of a drug trafficking crime.” deciding to buy the medication was once evidently a crime—but can it's stated that the defendant really “used” the gun through the crime? this kind of query is on the center of felony interpretation.
felony interpretation is outfitted round one key query: via what regular should still felony texts be interpreted? the normal doctrine is that phrases will be given their “ordinary meaning”: phrases in felony texts will be interpreted in mild of authorized criteria of communique. but usually, courts fail to correctly give some thought to context, consult with flawed dictionary definitions, or differently misconceive how the normal that means of phrases will be made up our minds. during this e-book, Brian Slocum builds his argument for a brand new approach to interpretation through asking obtrusive, but principally missed, questions. What makes one specific that means the “ordinary” one, and the way precisely do courts conceptualize the weather of normal meaning? Ordinary Meaning provides a much-needed, revised framework, boldly educating these concerned with the legislation in how the elements of standard which means may still accurately be pointed out and built in our sleek criminal system.

Show description

Read or Download Ordinary Meaning: A Theory of the Most Fundamental Principle of Legal Interpretation PDF

Best linguistics books

An Introduction to Discourse Analysis: Theory & Method

Assuming no past wisdom of linguistics, Gee provides either a concept of language-in-use, in addition to a style of analysis. this system is made of a suite of instruments of enquiry and methods for utilizing them. views from numerous techniques and disciplines, together with utilized linguistics, schooling, psychology, anthropology, and communique, are integrated to assist scholars and students a number of backgrounds formulate their very own perspectives on discourse research.

Cliffs Study Solver English Grammar

The CliffsStudySolver workbooks mix 20 percentage evaluation fabric with eighty percentage perform difficulties (and the solutions! ) to aid make your classes stick. CliffsStudySolver English Grammar is for college students who are looking to toughen their wisdom with a learn-by-doing method. within, you will get the perform you want to examine English grammar with problem-solving instruments similar to * transparent, concise studies of each subject * perform difficulties in each bankruptcy - with motives and strategies * A diagnostic pretest to evaluate your present talents * A full-length examination that adapts in your ability point A thesaurus, a listing of normally misused phrases, and punctuation and capitalization ideas may help converse successfully.

Novels of the Contemporary Extreme

This publication investigates a brand new type of fiction that's at the moment rising in modern literature around the globe. 'Novels of the modern severe' - from North and South the United States, from Europe, the center East and Asia - are set in a global either just like and various from our personal: a hyper genuine, frequently apocalyptic global steadily invaded by means of pop culture, permeated with know-how and ruled through destruction.

Additional info for Ordinary Meaning: A Theory of the Most Fundamental Principle of Legal Interpretation

Example text

Chapter 4 will argue that some conversational implicatures, viewed as systematic aspects of language rather than being dependent on actual authorial intent, can be determinants of ordinary meaning. For purposes of this chapter, distinctions between “utterance meaning” and “what is communicated” are not relevant if both are reviewed as depending on objective, rather than intentional, determinants of meaning. The second way to view category (3) is through “utterer’s meaning,” which holds that the utterer’s intent determines meaning, regardless of 40 chapter two whether the meaning was recognized via words and syntactic structures or other publicly available indicators of meaning, or, for some, regardless of whether the meaning was recognized at all by the relevant listeners or hearers.

These concerns and motivations may have no direct correspondence to nonlegal interpretation of texts. Nevertheless, the basic intentionalist position on the nature of language and interpretation is the same, regardless of the type of text at issue. In particular, the constitutive claim of intentionalism is that the meaning of a conversational utterance or a text is identical to the speaker or author’s intended meaning (meaning thesis). 1 Undoubtedly, part of the allure of intentionalism is that alternatives to its meaning and interpretation theses are not as intuitive.

Thus, the philosophical concept of literal meaning differs from a proper conception of the ordinary meaning doctrine. 7: Overview of the Book Although the ordinary meaning concept is not coterminous with textualism, the plain meaning rule or literal meaning, it is, like those other concepts, necessarily based on an “objective” view of meaning because its content is based on determinants of meaning other than the content the ordinary meaning doctrine 27 of the author’s communicative intentions. As indicated at the beginning of this chapter, the constituent question of what makes some meaning the ordinary one and the evidential question of how the determinants of ordinary meaning are identified and conceptualized are thus of crucial importance to the interpretation of legal texts.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.20 of 5 – based on 49 votes